The 2010-S Millard Fillmore Dollar is worth anywhere from $3 in standard proof condition to over $50 in top-tier deep cameo grades. If you have found this shiny gold-colored coin in your pocket change or an old collection, you are looking at a special “Proof” edition minted specifically for collectors.

Condition / Grade	Estimated Value
PR65 (Proof Grade)	$3.50 – $5.00
PR69 (Near Perfect)	$12.00 – $18.00
PR70 (Perfect Grade)	$45.00 – $85.00

Understanding the 2010-S Millard Fillmore Presidential Dollar

The Millard Fillmore dollar was the 13th release in the United States Mint’s Presidential $1 Coin Program. This series, which debuted in 2007, sought to honor every deceased U.S. President with a unique golden-colored coin. While millions were minted for circulation in Philadelphia and Denver, the coins bearing the “S” mint mark were produced exclusively at the San Francisco Mint.

If you are unsure whether your coin is a rare proof or a standard business strike, using a top coin identifier app can help you distinguish between the different finishes. Professional collectors often turn to CoinKnow to get instant historical data on these modern issues.

The Fillmore dollar features a portrait of the 13th President on the obverse and the Statue of Liberty on the reverse. Because these “S” mint coins were never intended to spend at a grocery store, they usually retain a mirror-like surface. However, finding one in actual circulation today is a rare treat, as it likely escaped from a broken-up collector set.

Identifying the Proof Finish and S Mint Mark

What makes the 2010-S Millard Fillmore dollar stand out is its “Proof” finish. Proof coins are struck using special polished dies and planchets (blanks), resulting in a high-contrast appearance. On a high-quality “S” dollar, the raised parts of the design (like Fillmore’s face) look frosted, while the background (the field) looks like a dark mirror.

The “S” mint mark is located on the edge of the coin, not on the flat surface. This was a unique design choice for the Presidential series. You will find the year, the “E Pluribus Unum” motto, and the mint mark “S” inscribed along the rim. If your coin has a “P” or “D” instead, it is a standard circulation coin worth exactly one dollar in used condition.

Because these edge inscriptions can wear down easily, collectors recommend using CoinKnow to help zoom in on high-resolution photos of the rim. This ensures you aren’t mistaking a dirty “P” for an “S.” The visual clarity of these coins is what drives the 2010 dollar coin price points among enthusiasts who want the best-looking specimens for their albums.

Factors Determining the Value of a 2010-S Fillmore Dollar

Most 2010-S Millard Fillmore dollars are found in “Proof 69” condition, which is almost perfect. Because the San Francisco Mint handles these coins with extreme care, they don’t usually have the scratches found on regular coins. However, the move from a PR69 to a PR70 (a perfect score) can double or triple the value of the coin.

Environmental damage is the biggest enemy of value for these coins. Even though they look like gold, they are actually made of a copper core with a manganese-brass cladding. This mixture can “milk spot” or develop hazy clouds on the surface if exposed to humidity. A coin with clear, deep mirrors will always command a premium over a hazy one.

Feature	Impact on Value
Perfect Surfaces (PR70)	High Increase ($50+)
Deep Cameo (DCAM)	Moderate Increase
Haze or Fingerprints	Significant Decrease
Edge Nicks	Minor Decrease

Are There Any Rare Errors for the 2010-S Fillmore Coin?

While the San Francisco Mint has very high quality control, errors can occasionally slip through. For the 2010-S Millard Fillmore dollar, collectors often look for “Edge Lettering Errors.” Because the lettering is applied in a separate step after the coin is struck, it is possible for the text to be missing or doubled.

Missing edge lettering on a proof coin is exceptionally rare and could be worth hundreds of dollars. Another common point of interest is the “Position A vs Position B” lettering. This refers to whether the edge text is upright or upside down when the President’s face is up. However, for Presidential dollars, both positions are considered normal and do not usually add extra value.

If you think you see something strange about the rim of your coin, use CoinKnow to compare it to known error databases. Understanding the current Fillmore coin market values is essential before trying to sell an error coin to a dealer, as you want to ensure you have a “true” mint error rather than post-mint damage.

How to Store and Preserve Your Presidential Proof Dollars

Since the 2010-S Millard Fillmore dollar is a “base metal” coin (non-precious), it is highly susceptible to the oils on your skin. If you touch the mirror-like surface with your fingers, your fingerprints may eventually eat into the finish, leaving a permanent mark that ruins the grade. Always handle these coins by the edges.

Ideally, a 2010-S dollar should be kept in its original US Mint plastic lens or a PVC-free “flip” or airtight capsule. Storing them in a cool, dry place prevents the manganese-brass from oxidizing and turning a dull brown color. If you found your coin in a “junk bin” at a coin shop, it’s likely already “impaired,” meaning it has scratches that limit its value to about $1.50 to $2.00.

For those building a complete set of Presidential Dollars, keeping the 2010-S in pristine condition is vital. These coins were issued alongside those of James Buchanan, Abraham Lincoln, and Andrew Johnson. Together, they represent a pivotal era in American history, and a high-grade set is a wonderful heirloom to pass down.

Summary of Price Trends for 2010-S Dollar Coins

The market for modern Presidential dollars is generally stable. While they are not “get rich quick” coins like a 19th-century silver dollar, they are affordable entry points for new hobbyists. The 2010-S Millard Fillmore dollar has seen a slight uptick in interest as more people try to complete “album sets” that require the S-mint proof versions.

Most sales happen on platforms like eBay or at local coin shows. In these venues, a raw (ungraded) 2010-S Fillmore dollar typically sells for $3 to $7 once you account for shipping. Professionally graded coins (by services like PCGS or NGC) are where the higher prices are found.

Sales Venue	Price Range	Notes
eBay (Raw)	$4.00 – $8.00	Includes shipping costs
Coin Shop	$2.00 – $5.00	Bulk pricing possible
Auction (Graded PR70)	$50.00+	Requires professional certification

FAQ

Q: Is the 2010-S Millard Fillmore dollar made of real gold?

A: No, it contains no gold. The “golden” color comes from a mixture of copper, zinc, manganese, and nickel. While it looks like gold, its value is based on its collectibility and rarity as a proof coin, not its metal content.

Q: Can I spend this coin at a store?

A: Yes, it is legal tender. However, it is worth at least $2 or $3 even in poor condition because it is a proof coin. Spending it for just $1 means you are losing money. It is better to sell it to a collector or keep it as an investment.

Q: How many 2010-S Millard Fillmore dollars were made?

A: The US Mint produced approximately 2,224,613 Millard Fillmore proof coins. While this sounds like a lot, it is much lower than the 74 million circulation coins made in Philadelphia and Denver that same year.

Q: Why is my 2010 dollar coin missing the date?

A: Check the edge! Presidential dollars have the date, mint mark, and “E Pluribus Unum” inscribed on the side of the coin. If the edge is smooth and has no writing at all, you have a rare “Plain Edge” error which can be quite valuable.

Q: What is the highest price ever paid for a Fillmore dollar?

A: High-grade PR70 Deep Cameo specimens can occasionally fetch over $100 at professional auctions if the coin is exceptionally beautiful and has a “First Strike” designation on the label.